Re: Gadget stalling without apparent reason

From: Carsten Frigaard <>
Date: Wed, 7 Sep 2011 10:18:48 +0200

What version of GADGET are you using?..I know of a issue similar to
ours in the SPH part, that makes the simulations run forever.

This particular defect was fixed in the latest minor GADGET release
(2.0.7 as I remember) - run a diff on the new and old source-code to
pinpoint the change, its just a one or two-line fix.

Carsten Eie Frigaard

2011/9/7 Enrique Vazquez <>:
> Hi,
> I'm submitting some test runs on my new 180-core cluster, but I'm
> encountering a very strange behavior: a run that I had performed in
> my previous cluster (118^3 SPH particles, no DM particles, on 8 CPUs),
> with identical parameters, and only the compile options being different
> to fit the new system, runs fine on 8 cores, but when I run it run on 32
> cores, it only advances up to a certain time, and then ceases to advance any
> further. It generally stops somewhere near the tree calculation, either
> while doing the domain decomposition, or while computing the tree force,
> or while computing the potential for all particles. Other runs I'm doing
> with larger SPH particle numbers (up to 27 million) on up to 128 cores
> act the same way.
> The strange part is that there's no crash. The system behaves as if it
> had entered an infinite loop, with the processors still crunching at full
> speed, but no further advance in simulation time occurs. No error messages
> are displayed, and the last timestep printed is perfectly normal (0.146).
> Because the problem occurs for 32 cores but not for 8, I guess it's some
> problem with MPI.
> I'm running Gadget2, with a few modifications by us to include extra ISM physics,
> on AMD 12-core processors, using OpenMPI and Intel compilers. The connectivity
> is Infiniband. Any suggestions or insight will be greatly appreciated!
> Best regards,
> Enrique
> -----------------------------------------------------------
> If you wish to unsubscribe from this mailing, send mail to
> with a subject of:  unsubscribe gadget-list
> A web-archive of this mailing list is available here:
Received on 2011-09-07 10:18:51

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.0 : 2023-01-10 10:01:31 CET